Message to Congress: COBRA Bites

I am a statistic, one of the millions of Americans laid off in early 2009. And thus, my family is currently insured through COBRA, the federal program that guarantees continued health coverage for people who have left full-time jobs. The acronym stands for Consolidated Omnibus Budget Reconciliation Act, but that’s just gobbledy gook. They could have named it a million different things that would have resulted in much less ominous acronyms. Instead, Congress was onto something when they named it after one of the most iconic poisonous snakes on earth—not to mention the terrorist bunch of bad guys on the old “GI Joe” cartoons. (Yo Joe!)

I know that COBRA is better than nothing. But there’s got to be a better way. Over the course of a year, factoring in our COBRA premiums and the kick-in-the-balls 2 percent administrative fee, my family’s health insurance bill is about $16,000 normally (not factoring in co-pays, ER visits, outside-network charges, and such). A provision in the stimulus bill is covering a good chunk of that for nine months, and for this my family is very grateful. But this is no long-term solution.

So, let me join millions of others and ask Congress to put their squabbles aside and come up with a workable long-term solution.

The big question is what the heck we should do. One of the best stories I’ve seen about healthcare in America was on “Frontline” a while back. As the show explains, the U.S. spends an absurd amount on costs that have nothing to do with providing actual care. Our administrative costs are completely out of whack with what other countries spend—not surprising, seeing as we get about 15 or 20 letters in the mail every month related to our coverage, and we still wind up having to call once or twice a month and speak with a vaguely helpful customer service representative to clear up some or other matter.

The “Frontline” story also made clear that something’s got to give. We’re just not that rich a nation to sustain things. Even while I had a full-time job, my health insurance premiums went up about 10 percent every year. How could that work in the long run? Sacrifices need to be made, and the two big ones are probably that doctors, hospitals, and pharmaceutical companies will make less money, and patients will receive somewhat worse, perhaps slower treatment (at least in terms of access to experimental and expensive drugs and procedures). I think I can deal with that, so long as it costs me a lot less than $16,000 a year. And oh yeah, I don’t want anyone in my family to die because of red tape.

Related Topics: COBRA, government, healthcare, Uncategorized, Saving, Saving & Spending, Uncategorized
  • http://ahoving.wordpress.com/ ahoving

    Thanks for adding to the discussion, which I have been following at http://twitter.com/COBRArules. My proposal is that the Federal govt begin by making COBRA coverage (as well as the subsidy for those unemployed) permanent. How would you like that?

  • Brad Tuttle

    Well, that’d be a start. At least people couldn’t be denied coverage, which you can be on the open market right now. Still, the expense is a killer, and I really don’t think healthcare should be tied to employment, which COBRA is (you get it via your former employer). We all want entrepreneurs to start up businesses nowadays, you know–jumpstart the economy and all–but the whole healthcare issue can kill a small business, and who knows how many would-be business owners don’t even go there because they don’t want to deal with healthcare. Most of all, I’m disgusted that such a huge portion of healthcare costs go to adminstrative stuff (paperwork, basically), rather than actual care. For every doctor’s visit someone in my family has, there seems to be three or four letters that come in the mail, along with a couple of phone calls. How is that efficient? Costs have to be brought under control, and streamlining operations seems like the obvious first step. I’d vote for Atul Gawande, the doctor who wrote the New Yorker story I referenced, to oversee things as some sort of healthcare czar. Of all the people I’ve heard discussing healthcare, he makes the most sense.

  • luvloogie

    I moved my daughters out of COBRA into a state-run public option. No denials; no phone calls. Doctors and therapists are getting paid. AETNA DENIED my younger, prematurely-born daughter’s occupational and physical therapy because it was a “developmental” issue and not a diagnosed neurological disability. The public option, however, is paying for everything, and the doctors don’t have to haggle.

    She needed eye-surgery because she wasn’t focusing properly. No delay. We were scheduled for the doctor’s next surgery day and we were the first patient scheduled for that day.

    The republicans, blue dog dems, and the insurance industry racket ARE LYING TO YOU!!! Wake up America!!!

  • digibella

    Expand the county health departments that currently help those without insurance. Extend coverage to everyone. Implement the public option. Health care is not a commodity one gets to choose whether or not to consume, it is time America faced this fact. Every citizen is entitled to necessary health care. We can afford it. Let’s just do it.

  • tyrantking

    How about getting rid of for-profit health care. That would mean non-profit health insurance companies and non-profit hospitals. Eliminate their profit motive and see how much more reasonable health care expenses become.

  • Brad Tuttle

    In theory, all hospitals and healthcare in general should be non-profits. They provide service to the public, arguably the most important service there is. A lot of doctors might have problems with their new status as government employees, right alongside cops and folks at the DMV. But if taxpayers subsidize doctors’ educations, that should help a bit. Your money goes to the police academy (not the Steve Guttenburg films, though I am a fan), right? Why not medical schools? Doctors will need to be compensated, starting with getting their educations covered. I’m sure lots of doctors will welcome the government if it covers their burdensome malpractice insurance premiums, too.

  • dd1956

    I agree…something has got to give to realize real cost reduction.

    Below are two additional ideas…

    – Eliminate State Regulatory agencies. There is no value in having
    50 different sets of rules

    – Tort reform to significantly limit medical malpractice costs.
    This would serve two purposes…enable doctors to charge lower
    prices AND encourage more people to become doctors (increasing
    supply

  • http://cheapskate.blogs.time.com/2009/06/11/doctors-say-no-healthcare-for-you/ Doctors Say: No Healthcare for You! – The Cheapskate Blog – TIME.com

    [...] I said a couple days ago, a transformation of our current healthcare mess will affect patients, doctors, [...]

  • http://cheapskate.blogs.time.com/2009/09/21/the-hagglers-guide-to-cheaper-health-care/ The Haggler’s Guide to Cheaper Health Care – The Cheapskate Blog – TIME.com

    [...] in the LA Times. After quitting his job more than a year ago, Moore received insurance through COBRA (which bites, btw), paying nearly $450 a month. When his access to COBRA ended, he simply decided to not bother paying [...]

  • http://www.curediverticulitisnow.net/waiting-for-reform-the-unemployed-get-a-health-care-cobra-gift-yahoo-news Waiting for Reform: The Unemployed Get a Health Care COBRA Gift – Yahoo! News

    [...] Under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act (ARRA), the federal subsidies pay 65% of the cost of COBRA premiums. Originally, the subsidy was to expire after nine months and unemployed families would have seen their health care premiums spike on average from $389 to $1,111 per month. This tripling of cost could have caused many families to drop their health care coverage just as Congress is on the cusp of passing the most far-reaching health care reform legislation in history. (See the Cheapskate blogger on COBRA.) [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus