Doctors Say: No Healthcare for You!

President Obama is expected to address the American Medical Association next week in Chicago, but before he has a chance to, the powerful doctors’ lobbyist group with some 250,000 members already came out and said it opposes a government-funded healthcare plan. Why? They say they’re worried about you, the taxpayer.

Without private insurers, the group says via the Times, “the corresponding surge in public plan participation would likely lead to an explosion of costs that would need to be absorbed by taxpayers.” But as the Huffington Post reports, the AMA has a seven-decade history of opposing pretty much every healthcare reform effort under the sun.

Like I said a couple days ago, a transformation of our current healthcare mess will affect patients, doctors, and hospitals alike. Many doctors aren’t excited by the idea of becoming government employees—or rather, they’re not excited by getting paid like a government employee. After dropping a couple hundred thousand bucks on their educations, they understandably need to be paid better than somebody at the DMV.

But is this really about money? Or control? Something else? The only reason anything’s happening at all is because health costs are out of control in the first place. Can they really get much worse? (I guess things can always get worse.) I have to think that the AMA has announced its opposition merely as a start to the negotiation process. They want to be calling some of the shots in whatever plan becomes reality. And if nothing happens? Doctors, as you may have noticed, are doing pretty well for themselves as is. As for the 45 million uninsured in America, apparently that’s not their problem. No wonder so many more people are turning to the web nowadays for medical advice.

Related Topics: American Medical Association, government, healthcare, Obama, Uncategorized, Saving & Spending, Uncategorized
  • Latest on Moneyland

    Ryan McVay / Getty Images

    Survey: Costco Given Retail Crown for Best Shopping Experience

    American consumers don’t just like buying in bulk—they like the shopping experience at one bulk-buying warehouse store a lot more compared to other retailers. Based on the results of a new survey, Costco has been named the retailer scoring the highest overall ratings with shoppers.

    Is an Amazon Store in the Real World a Good Idea?Daily Finance

    Getty Images

    Pizza Hut Valentine’s Day Special: Pizza Selling for $10,010*

    *The deal also includes flowers, limo service, fireworks, a videographer, photographer, and a red ruby ring—that you’re supposed to propose with. Whether you propose before or after eating pizza, breadsticks, and cinnamon sticks is your call.

  • guillo28

    To state that ” Doctors are doing pretty well for themselves ” is like saying ” a diabetic patient is doing as well as a healthy 2o year old “. Do you know why there are so few family physicians in the United States ? It is because they are doing double the work an specialist is doing for half the pay. And multiple studies show that family physicians are the only ones who have the know-how to provide good quality AND affordable care. As for the AMA, they are basically in the specialist pockets. I would pay more attention to what the AAFP would have to say.

  • xxchalice

    Doctors make an absurd amount of money for what little they do, especially the specialists. They don’t like the fact the government would force more reasonable pricing down their throats so they will fight this tooth and nail. Having the government involved is not optimal; however, the current system is fatally flawed and has been so for decades. Other countries have provided comfortable, though not extravagant payments for their doctors and we should do the same. Pay for quality, not quantity and lower the barriers of entry for doctors into the profession. A public plan will not do these things directly, but it could add some sanity to the current situation. The reason the doctors most fear this legislation is because they know people will take to it in droves. I have a great plan myself and know for a fact I would be give the government plan a definite look when established, especially if it is as good as the one our legislators currently receive at our expense… I want some of that.

  • usparliament

    “Do no harm”… that’s the oath isn’t it? In the United States, about 20,000 people die each year because they don’t have health insurance.

    The AMA would now like to deliver another few hundred thousand death sentences. Harm? More like genocide.

    http://www.usparliament.blogspot.com

  • thefoff

    Interesting to me that the argument the AMA used is that “having a private health care option will drive existing insurers out of business, leaving only a socialized health care system behind.”

    Um, does anybody really think that Aetna would go out of business because of a completely voluntary public health insurance option? If anything, they would go out of business because of some form of greedy “health insurance default swaps” and not because people have the power to choose another option. Or, are they afraid that they will be forced to actually fulfill their promise to people who buy their insurance from them and actually provide health care??

    Now, that might eat into their 400% profit increase over the past 10 years, but I imagine that the total cost to them would be less than the amount of money they currently spend buying off members of Congress.

  • http://cheapskate.blogs.time.com/2009/06/12/who-is-screwed-the-worst/ Who is Screwed the Worst? – The Cheapskate Blog – TIME.com

    [...] Doctors: If a healthcare overall takes place, doctors—and specialists in particular—may be on a completely different pay scale, which is one reason I suspect the American Medical Association has come out against reform. [...]

  • vjtixnix

    It will be interesting to see doctor’s reactions to the new bill. We can only wait and see.
    http://members.tixnix.com

blog comments powered by Disqus