Why Isn’t Your Roof White Already?

Studies are showing that most—but not all–Americans should be following U.S. Secretary of Energy Steve Chu’s recommendation that people paint their roofs white. On hot days, it’s 20 percent or more cheaper to air-condition a house with a white roof rather than a traditional charcoal-colored asphalt roof. It’s another simple solution for saving money.

If you’re consuming less energy, it obviously saves you some cash, and it also cuts back on carbon dioxide emissions. The Times explains the science:

The physics behind cool roofs is simple. Solar energy delivers both light and heat, and the heat from sunlight is readily absorbed by dark colors. (An asphalt roof in New York can rise to 180 degrees on a hot summer day.) Lighter colors, however, reflect back a sizable fraction of the radiation, helping to keep a building — and, more broadly, the city and Earth — cooler. They also re-emit some of the heat they absorb.

But a white roof might not be for everyone. A dark roof is exactly what you want in northerly locales in the winter, when you’re trying to attract the heat and lessen the cost of heating your home:

Some roofing specialists and architects argue that supporters fail to account for climate differences or the complexities of roof construction. In cooler climates, they say, reflective roofs can mean higher heating bills.

Scientists acknowledge that the extra heating costs may outweigh the air-conditioning savings in cities like Detroit or Minneapolis.
But for most types of construction, they say, light roofs yield significant net benefits as far north as New York or Chicago.

Although those cities have cold winters, they are heat islands in the summer, with hundreds of thousands of square feet of roof surface absorbing energy.

Related Topics: roofs, Steve Chu, white roof, Borrowing, Budgeting, Real Estate & Homes, Saving & Spending
  • Latest on Moneyland

    manuel velasco / Getty Images

    Wednesday Is For Lovers of Cheap Wine

    On a Wednesday not long ago, the flash-deal wine specialty site WTSO (WinesTilSoldOut) sold more than 87,000 bottles in a single day, grossing over $1 million in sales. Another Cheapskate Wednesday is set to take place on May 16.

    Cheap Thrills: 8 Ways to Save Money at the Amusement ParkDaily Finance

    Getty Images

    Google and Apple Top List of Companies Grads Most Want To Work For

    While America’s leading tech companies (again) top the annual list of popular employers for soon-to-be graduates, you may be surprised at three companies that rose from the grave of popular opinion in 2012.

  • ohiopapa

    I painted the north side of the roof over our FROG (free room over garage) a couple of weeks ago (note to others – consult the wife first!) with some left-over white paint. On a sunny day, the dark side is 120+ degrees, and the white side is under 100, dropping the room temperature a couple of degrees. I’m sure if I’d had the nerve/stupidity to paint both sides, the drop would be have been even more pronounced. Still negotiating painting more of the roof.
    You have to be careful not to make the coat too thick – I’ve read that if you “seal” your roof, it won’t shed water properly, and could lead to roof damage.

  • Brad Tuttle

    Cool. What kind of paint did you use? Something made especially for roofs? And did your wife have a problem with the color and the changed look of the house? Or that you were up on the roof risking life and limb?

  • ohiopapa

    I’ve got to admit, it was not well thought-out: “Damn it’s hot in that room… what did Steven Chu say? Oh, yeah, paint the roof white!” So off I went with some ceiling white paint. Probably exterior white would have been better, and I’m wondering if semi-gloss would be more weather-resistant than flat. Any experimenters out there?
    As to the wife, I think I should have consulted her on something relatively permanent and co-owned. I’m still waiting for a warm day to take her up there to feel the difference, and I hope that will make her a believer. But in SE Ohio (as elsewhere), we’ve had a cool and rainy summer.

    On a tangential yet cheapskate note: to shade the front of the house (and halve our electric bill), we should have solar panels installed next year with no money up-front, thanks to the Athens Solar Initiative. If it works as expected, other states should be beating a path to Ohio’s door to copy the program.

    Brad, I’ve got emails for all mentioned, if you want more info.

    //www.athensnews.com/news/local-news/28547-city-program-could-make-it-cheaper-for-homes-to-go-solar

  • kgmarkey

    Such an elegant and simple solution. May take some time to adjust to the new aesthetics, but I’m sure white roofs eventually will join power lines, fire hydrants, and guardrails and such as things we don’t even notice. My only question is about the (in)advisability of white roofs in northern climes. In many cold locations, a reflective layer of white snow already covers well-insulated roofs for much of the winter (mine was pretty much buried from December through March of last year). Lightening the shingle color under all that snow wouldn’t seem to have much effect on heating costs.

  • Brad Tuttle

    Snow! Very good point. I wish some Energy Dept. official would offer some guidance about what to do. What sort of paint? How to best apply? What sort of roofs, exactly, does this work and not work with? If this info is out there, I’d love to get my hands on it and spread the word. To get lots of people to do this, we need specifics, not just “go paint your roof white.” If this catches on, you know painting and/or roofing companies will be advertising specials for painting roofs before you know it.

  • ohiopapa

    I just asked Steven Chu on Facebook for guidance to roof painting and asked him to reply here.

  • ohiopapa

    Until Secretary Chu responds, I leave you with this quote from the CSM story below: “If the estimated 360,000 square miles (less than 1 percent of the world’s land surface) covered by urban rooftops and pavement were a white or light color, enough sunlight would be reflected back into space to delay climate change by about 11 years”

    http://features.csmonitor.com/innovation/2008/10/03/how-white-roofs-shine-bright-green/

  • http://cheapskate.blogs.time.com/2009/08/04/prices-for-solar-panels-are-no-longer-sky-high/ Prices for Solar Panels Are No Longer Sky High – The Cheapskate Blog – TIME.com

    [...] Oh, and before you install solar panels on your house, you may or may not want to paint your roof white. [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus