Why Are You Still Paying to Make Cell Phone Calls?

The average iPhone user forks over $95 a month to AT&T, and more than half of that covers voice accounts. Now that AT&T has approved applications like Skype, which allow users to make calls—even international calls—for free or very cheap via the Internet, it seems like only a matter of time before customers change the way they make calls, saving themselves an easy $50 or $60 a month in the process.

Some specifics from the WSJ:

While AT&T doesn’t let iPhone customers sign up for data-only plans, customers could downshift from an unlimited voice-minute plan to the lowest tier of minutes. Then they could use Internet services for free or very cheap calls, taking advantage of the unlimited nature of AT&T’s data plans.

J.P. Morgan analyst Mike McCormack estimates that voice accounts for $50-$60 of the roughly $95 in monthly revenue generated from the average iPhone user. He estimates that if an average user drops to the cheapest $39.99 voice plan, AT&T would lose between 20% and 33% of voice revenue.

The technology required to make phone calls and send text messages is very cheap. Internet calls are virtually free. A text message costs a cell provider all of 0.3¢. (Yes, it costs your provider roughly one penny for every 3 text messages it transmits.) Yet what does your provider charge you for that text? Maybe 10¢ or 20¢. That dime or couple of dimes does not seem like a lot of money—but it represents a phenomenal markup, an easy, highly profitable revenue generator. For anyone who has a teenager who sends thousands of texts per month, it also represents a big chunk of your bill.

These are such disproportional markups that there’s no way they can last. Not in a competitive marketplace anyway. AT&T must sense that the jig is up, even if it does have an exclusive agreement with the phone everybody seems to want (for now, at least). The provider gave in to Internet calling apps for Skype and Vonage, making it possible for users to dial for next to nothing. As the quality of Internet dialing improves and free Wi-Fi continues to expand, more and more people will go this way—perhaps exclusively this way.

AT&T hasn’t given up entirely, however. On another front, it is still battling it out with Google by saying that the way its Google Voice service blocks calls is a violation of federal law. Google Voice, which lets users combine land lines, mobile lines, and messaging into one number, was also rejected by Apple’s iPhone. Why? The argument is hard to follow and doesn’t really make sense, as the Washington Post points out.

Regardless of how AT&T and Apple deal with Google, and regardless of how all of the traditional cell phone providers deal with each other and Internet calling services, the path is cleared for much cheaper phone calls in the near future. Now, really.

Will the average cell phone bill be slashed in half accordingly? That remains to be seen.

In other news, the NY Times offers tips on making the torturous process of shopping for a cell phone—”about as much fun as buying a used car,” per the article—a bit less painful. This is no one-stop shopping procedure. A three-step strategy is required, per the Times:

There is a way to approach the task with a small measure of logic. To boil it down, the process is a three-step boogie: go online to narrow your choices, go offline to test a few, go back online to buy one. Spend a day doing this, and you can avoid two years of cellphone remorse.

Read the full story here.

Read more: The People vs Cell Phone Tyranny: A Case for Lower Monthly Bills

Related Topics: AT&T, cell phones, families & children, freebies, Google, Google Voice, Skype, Vonage, Saving & Spending
  • http://www.ryanreales.com/2009/10/08/nokia-888-cellphone/ Nokia 888 cellphone

    [...] Why Are You Still Paying to Make Cell Phone Calls? – The … [...]

  • sh5105

    A text message costs a cell provider all of 0.3¢. (Yes, it costs your provider roughly one penny for every 33 text messages it transmits.)
    Read more: http://cheapskate.blogs.time.com/2009/10/08/why-are-you-still-paying-to-make-cell-phone-calls/#ixzz0TN8tobO9

    0.3 cents is 3 texts per cent, not 33. 0.03 per text is 33 texts per cent. You are off with a decimal point somewhere

  • sh5105

    perhaps you and Verizion can get together and figure out fractions sometime.

    http://verizonmath.blogspot.com/

  • Brad Tuttle

    Whoops, my bad. Duh. Thanks

  • dbb10001

    Brad nice article. If the “average cell bill” is NOT “slashed in half accordingly,” I thought I’d add a resource for cutting down the wireless bills by at least a quarter, on average. I work for the consumer advocacy website http://www.fixmycellbill.com, powered by a company called Validas, where we slash the average cell bill by 22 percent. Validas acts as the wireless bodyguard protecting you against frivolous charges that over-inflate 8 out of 10 cell bills. You can find out for free if fixmycellbill.com can modify your wireless plan to better suit your usage by going to the website.

    For more info, check out Validas on Fox News at http://www.myfoxtampabay.com/dpp/consumer/conlaw/lower_cell_phone_bills_072409 .

    Good luck to everyone reading on cutting your Verizon costs, especially in this tough economy.

    Dylan
    Consumer Advocacy, fixmycellbill.com

  • http://discountbusinessassociation.com bizSavings

    The costs of making cell phone calls has risen over the years mostly due to data plans. Let’s hope that these costs are reduces soon. The largest carriers should give substantial discounts to businesses that use all of those great applications. The Discount Business Association supports savings for small businesses. http://discountbusinessassociation.com

  • luigi1980

    I think the buying strategy you describe is ok, but it’s not always appliable.
    We are constantly in a rush, we don’t have time to go shop by shop and compare prices and offers. We don’t have time to see our friends and family: that’s why we need a mobile phone!
    As far as call costs are concerned, I totally agree and I do appreciate your report.
    In Italy, for example, where I live, phone users pay the highest mobile call rates in the EU, but they go on using cell phones longer and longer…
    Commercials work wonders…

    Ciao from Italy

    http://testadicavolo.blogspot.com

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2010/01/05/in-the-future-no-more-%e2%80%a6-well-no-more-lots-of-things/ In the Future: No More … Well, No More Lots of Things – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] that fee-laden mobile-phone contracts may be goners, replaced by the practice of customers using wi-fi hotspots and free VoIP technologies like Skype to make [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2010/01/26/dont-want-to-pay-for-a-web-enabled-cell-phone-too-bad/ Don’t Want to Pay for a Web-Enabled Cell-Phone? Too Bad – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] But in some ways, you'll be the envy of people who own a smartphone such as the iPhone—and whose monthly bills are more than double what you'd pay, on [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2010/02/04/avoiding-americas-biggest-rip-offs/ Avoiding “America’s Biggest Rip-offs” – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] Messages. ALTERNATIVE: To avoid markups of as much as 6500% (yes 6500%, because texts cost next to nothing to transmit, yet you can be charged 20¢ a pop), get a cell phone plan that includes enough free text messaging [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2010/02/11/cheapest-prepaid-cell-phone-options-from-25-a-month-for-unlimited-talk-and-text/ Cheapest Prepaid Cell Phone Options: From $25 a Month for Unlimited Talk and Text – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] cell phones, Cricket TXTM8, prepaid cell phones, Straight Talk You're not going to see an iPhone or Google's Nexus One on this list. But if you're trying to trim monthly bills, a prepaid plan and [...]

  • kimberlygomez83

    For me personally, I was paying way too much in overage fees and contract issues. I was with my previous carrier for over 6 years, but I had to switch and I decided that I was going to try the prepaid market. I signed up with Walmart’s Straight Talk line and I’m very impressed so far despite negative reviews I’ve found. Their $45 unlimited plan is saving me over $50 a month and $600 a year versus my previous carrier and without dealing with contracts. The ST Verizon network is strong and dependable and their selection is more than reasonable, especially for a prepaid company. I was able to transfer my number, but not my contacts at this point. People need to keep in mind that prepaid companies, particularly Straight Talk, are new and expanding everyday. I love the ease of Straight Talk and the savings – prepaid really is the way to go.

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2010/05/14/cell-phone-news-prepaid-phones-are-hot-actual-calls-on-cell-phones-are-not/ Cell-Phone News: Prepaid Phones Are Hot, Actual Calls on Cell Phones Are Not – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] that it'll allow the iPhone to be used on a prepaid basis. That's no shocker, considering that the average iPhone user pays $95 a month to AT&T, and the company obviously isn't eager to allow those customers to opt out of their [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2010/07/08/quick-tip-free-text-messaging/ Quick Tip: Free Text Messaging – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] phones, Google Voice, iPhone, Text Free, text messages Considering that a text message costs a fraction of a penny to transmit, it's absurd that some consumers still pay 10¢ or 20¢ a pop for sending and receiving texts. Even [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2010/09/09/now-heres-what-a-smartphone-really-costs-you/ Now Here’s What a Smartphone Really Costs You – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] other monthly fees, you're paying at least $55 and up to $115 a month. A while back, I saw that the average iPhone user pays $95-a-month bill. Therefore, over two years' time, you're paying a minimum of $1,320 ($55 x 24 mos.), an average of [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2011/01/10/why-the-49-iphone-still-costs-too-much/ Why the $49 iPhone Still Costs Too Much – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] contract—are only a tiny fraction of what you'll pay over time for using it. By one account, the average iPhone user pays a $95-a-month bill to AT&T, and, doing the math to see what a smartphone really costs over time, once all the fees [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2011/04/04/ceo-math-according-to-atts-chief-executive-wireless-prices-have-decreased-by-50/ CEO Math: According to AT&T’s Chief Executive, Wireless Prices Have Decreased by 50% – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] for less, the typical consumer isn't paying all that much less. Stephenson has to know that the average iPhone user pays around $100 a month. And sure, you get more with a smartphone, but let's not pretend that the average consumer [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus