Ten Bizarre Theories on Saving and Spending

Poker teaches important lessons about saving and investing. Foreclosures are better than mortgage modification programs. Debit card overdraft fees are good for consumers. PMS is responsible for impulse purchases. There is no shortage of strange theories out there—and some of them are actually plausible.

1. Right now, you should be saving more and spending more—simultaneously. This is the basic (if conflicting) prescription for fixing the economy.

2. PMS made me do it. A survey reveals that women are more likely to make impulse buys in the ten days before their periods.

3. A quick self-affirmation increases self-control—and helps avoid impulse purchases. Studies by consumer psychologists show that when people take a moment to think about their core values in life, they have more control over what they do (and what they buy).

4. Debit card overdraft fees are good for consumers. This is an argument made by banks charging the overdraft fees, of course. The gist: Because banks make so much money off of a small percentage of customers hit with tons of overcharge fees, the rest of us who don’t incur overdrafts are able to get checking accounts and other services free of charge. Banks say if they weren’t reaping in the bucks through overdrafts, they’d have to start charging everyone for checking and other services.

5. Poker leads to financial wisdom. Managing your bankroll is supposedly akin to managing your savings, investments, and risk. Apparently, we’ve all got to learn when you hold ‘em, when to fold ‘em, when to walk away, and of course, when to run.

6. Free shipping is not always in your best interest. Consumers are total suckers for free shipping. Studies show that you’re four or five times more likely to make an online purchase if an item costs $5 but has free shipping as you are if the same item costs $2.50 and shipping costs $2.50.

7. Foreclosure proceedings, while expensive and time-consuming, are preferable to mortgage modifications. This is from the banks’ perspective, of course. But at some point, many homeowner find it is in their interest to simply walk away from their mortgages.

8. The $5 bill savings plan. In the November issue of Real Simple, a reader explains how he saved $2,000 for a family vacation to Cape Cod. He pays for everything in cash, and every time he received a $5 bill as part of his change, the fiver went into an envelope, then into a bank account that was separate from his main account—so he wouldn’t be tempted to dip into the $5 savings pile. Whatever works, right?

9. Penny pinching is like a fad diet. In both cases, the results are meager—and often don’t last. So says Jeff Yeager, a.k.a. the Ultimate Cheapskate, in this BankRate post.

10. The sex-housework link. Studies show that the more housework husbands and wives do, the more likely they are to have sex (presumably with their spouses). Admittedly, this isn’t really about saving or spending, unless you count the money you’re saving by not spending it on a cleaning service. I suppose if you do employ a cleaning service, however, in theory you’re more likely to have an affair with the maid.

Related Topics: consumer psychologist, debit cards, families & children, foreclosure, housework, Jeff Yeager, overdraft, PMS, poker, recession porn, recovery, saving theories, spending theories, Ultimate Cheapskate, Borrowing, Budgeting, Credit Cards, Mortgages, Real Estate & Homes, Saving & Spending
  • http://botd.wordpress.com/2009/10/25/top-posts-1276/ Top Posts « WordPress.com

    [...] Ten Bizarre Theories on Saving and Spending Poker teaches important lessons about saving and investing. Foreclosures are better than mortgage modification [...] [...]

  • http://cheapskate.blogs.time.com/2009/10/26/hey-joel-stein-where-are-my-trojkas/ Hey Joel Stein, Where Are My Trojkas? – The Cheapskate Blog – TIME.com

    [...] victim to a classic blunder, right up there with being suckered into buying stuff online because of a free shipping promotion and getting involved in a land war in [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2009/11/06/without-free-shipping-were-not-buying/ Without Free Shipping, We’re Not Buying – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] shipping sounds great, but it can make shoppers behave irrationally. Check out this story I've referenced before (see #6 on the list), which mentions that you're four or five times more likely to make an online [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2009/11/19/free-shipping-day-whats-the-deal/ Free Shipping Day: What’s the Deal? – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] aware that free shipping, while certainly welcomed, is known to make shoppers behave irrationally, buying stuff (or more stuff) than logic would dictate. In other words, take free shipping for what it is: a nice little discount to figure into your [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2009/12/02/what-the-x-men-old-pantyhose-and-pregnancy-tests-have-in-common/ What the X-Men, Old Pantyhose, and Pregnancy Tests Have in Common – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] bits of advice might be considered unusual, much like the theory that playing poker leads to financial wisdom or that filling your wallet with $100 bills saves money (because people are especially reluctant to [...]

  • http://aetechamerica.wordpress.com/2010/01/09/how-to-cut-grocery-bills-in-half/ How to Cut Grocery Bills in Half « Live Your Life Better – LYLB – AETech America's Blog

    [...] Say I’ve never saved coupons before. I’m a total neophyte at this. But, the recession is here. How do I start? I would recommend this no-clip coupon system: saving the entire circular from the Sunday paper, writing Sunday’s date on it, and saving them in a box. [Before I go shopping] I sit down with my stack, and in 10 minutes I can cut out just the ones I need for that shopping trip. Even a neophyte could do that reasonably. (Read 10 bizarre theories on saving and spending.) [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2010/01/25/saving-money-its-all-in-your-head/ Saving Money: It’s All in Your Head – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] Related: Ten Bizarre Theories on Saving and Spending [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2010/05/18/new-business-models-entrepreneurial-lessons-from-preachers-prostitutes-and-cockroaches/ New “Business Models”: Entrepreneurial Lessons from Preachers, Prostitutes, and Cockroaches – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] Related: Ten Bizarre Theories on Saving and Spending [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2010/06/11/what-ive-learned-from-a-year-of-blogging-about-saving-money/ What I’ve Learned from a Year of Blogging About Saving Money – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] There are also some odd theories on spending. Like that PMS is responsible for impulse spending. [...]

  • http://money.blogs.time.com/2010/12/17/qa-with-free-shipping-day-founder-luke-knowles/ Q&A with Free Shipping Day Founder Luke Knowles – It's Your Money – TIME.com

    [...] RELATED: Online Holiday Shopping Wars: Free Shipping Available from 6 Big Retailers, No Minimum Purchase Required Ten Bizarre Theories on Saving and Spending, Including Why Consumers Are Total Suckers for Free Ship… [...]

  • http://makeamerica.com/qa-with-free-shipping-day-founder-luke-knowles.html Q&A with Free Shipping Day Founder Luke Knowles | Make America

    [...] Holiday Shopping Wars: Free Shipping Available from 6 Big Retailers, No Minimum Purchase RequiredTen Bizarre Theories upon Saving as well as Spending, Including Why Consumers Are Total Suckers for … Posted in Latest News Tags: Amp, Canadian Residents, Christmas, Christmas Eve, consumers, [...]

  • http://carins.co.tv/qa-with-free-shipping-day-founder-luke-knowles.html Q&A with Free Shipping Day Founder Luke Knowles | Carins

    [...] Holiday Shopping Wars: Free Shipping Available from 6 Big Retailers, No Minimum Purchase RequiredTen Bizarre Theories on Saving and Spending, Including Why Consumers Are Total Suckers for Free Ship… This entry was posted in Google Trends and tagged Founder, free, Knowles, Luke, Shipping. [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus